Over the years, I’ve built up quite a collection: 10 tumblers from 10 different brands. They’ve become a great alternative to my best water bottles. While they are often made from the same high-quality materials, their construction is a bit different. Most tumblers feature a sleek, narrow bottom that fits into cup holders and a sturdy handle that people love, especially influencers.
To be honest, every time I use one, I feel a little bit like an influencer myself. Tumblers just have that trendy, polished vibe that makes any drink feel a little more special.
If you’re thinking of joining the tumbler trend and getting one for yourself, this ranking will help you make the right choice. I’ve tested all of them in my daily life, so you can avoid the trial and error and go straight for something that works.
One thing worth pointing out is that all the tumblers in this ranking have a few things in common. They are made from premium stainless steel. They come with a handle and a straw. They are vacuum insulated with either double or triple walls. And yes, they all fit perfectly in your car’s cup holder. So when you’re picking your favorite, you can focus on design, color, and brand without worrying about the basics.
Some of the links on this page are affiliate links. This means that if you click on one of the links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
Tumbler | Buy Now |
|---|---|
 Coldest Tumbler | Final Score: 5.0/5 |
 Stanley Quencher ProTour | Final Score: 4.6/5 |
 Owala Tumbler | Final Score: 4.5/5 |
 Simple Modern Trek Tumbler | Final Score: 4.2/5 |
 Hydro Flask Travel Tumbler | Final Score: 3.8/5 |
 YETI Rambler Tumbler | Final Score: 3.8/5 |
The Insulation Test
I tested all six tumblers in this ranking specifically for their insulation performance, so you can get that information right up front. Keep in mind, though, that while insulation is important, it’s not the only factor that determines a great tumbler. My final ranking also takes into account build quality, usability, design, and overall value.
The first test focused on how well each tumbler retained the temperature of plain water (without ice) over a 24-hour period. Surprisingly, the Simple Modern tumbler came out on top in this category. I didn’t expect that result, but it definitely stood out.
Coldest | Stanley | Owala | Simple Modern | Hydro Flask | YETI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Base temp. | 32.4°F (0.2°C) | 32.4°F (0.2°C) | 32.4°F (0.2°C) | 32.4°F (0.2°C) | 32.4°F (0.2°C) | 32.4°F (0.2°C) |
After 24 hours | 60.1°F (15.6°C) | 65.7°F (18.7°C) | 65.1°F (18.4°C) | 59°F (15°C) | 68°F (20°C) | 66.4°F (19.1°C) |
Keep in mind that this test was conducted without adding a single ice cube. If you fill roughly one-third of the tumbler with ice, each model should have no trouble keeping your water cold (below 59°F or 15°C) for a full 24 hours, and in some cases, even up to 2 to 3 days.
Next, I evaluated how well the tumblers could retain heat. This test is especially useful if you plan to use your tumbler for coffee, tea, or other hot drinks. Here, we had a tie between the Coldest and Simple Modern tumblers. Both performed exceptionally well and maintained heat for an impressive amount of time.
Coldest | Stanley | Owala | Simple Modern | Hydro Flask | YETI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Base temp. | 188.6°F (87°C) | 188.6°F (87°C) | 188.6°F (87°C) | 188.6°F (87°C) | 188.6°F (87°C) | 188.6°F (87°C) |
After 12 hours | 132.8°F (56°C) | Not intended to use with hot liquids | 109.4°F (43°C) | 132.8°F (56°C) | Not intended to use with hot liquids | Not intended to use with hot liquids |
Now that we’ve covered the insulation performance, let’s take a closer look at each tumbler individually, exploring their features, design, and why they might be the perfect fit for your lifestyle.
1st Place: Coldest Tumbler
Maybe you were expecting to see some of the usual big names like Owala or Hydro Flask at the top of the list. Honestly, I’m still surprised that not many people have heard of Coldest. I use their bottles and tumblers regularly, and I genuinely love them. I didn’t choose this tumbler for the number one spot just to stand out from other rankings online. I truly believe it’s the best tumbler available right now.
Let’s be honest. We all say we care about performance first, but when it comes to tumblers, aesthetics usually seal the deal. Coldest gets that. They offer an incredible range of colors and styles, and I’m not just talking about pink vs. yellow. You’ll find beautiful gradients, glitter finishes, and some pretty bold designs. I especially like names like “Cosmic Ice Glitter” and “Forbidden Nova”.
I personally went with “Gold Reflections.” Just look at it and tell me it doesn’t stand out. I can confirm it does. I’ve had people stare when I take a sip, and I don’t blame them.
Now, the lids. One of my favorite things about this tumbler is that it comes with three different lids in the box. That kind of versatility is rare. It’s actually the only tumbler in this ranking that gives you options right out of the gate.
You’re probably wondering: will the lids leak? That’s a fair concern, especially since most people don’t expect tumblers to be leakproof. I tested this thoroughly, shaking it and rolling it on the floor with each lid attached. The result: Not a single drop escaped.
Here’s a quick breakdown of the lids:
Sports Lid: Although it’s marketed for sports, it’s great for everyday use too. It’s completely leakproof, as long as you remember to fold the straw down properly. It doesn’t have a traditional straw but rather a small spout, which I find easy and comfortable to drink from. The lid also includes a two-finger carry handle — always a plus for portability.
Sip Lid: This one has a feature that honestly blew me away. At first glance, it looks like there’s just a thin membrane where the straw goes in, but once you remove the straw, it seals itself tightly. I didn’t have to do anything. It just works. And if you prefer to keep the straw in, Coldest includes a small rubber cap that covers the top of the straw, making it leakproof even then. That’s almost unheard of.
Chug Lid: This is my personal favorite. While I’ve seen similar versions of the sports and sip lids from other brands, the design of the chug lid is something new. It’s incredibly solid and features two layers of protection. First, there’s a spout cover that only opens when you press a button — it won’t pop open on its own. On top of that, there’s a lock that prevents the button from being pressed accidentally. So in terms of security, this lid is basically double-leakproof. It also has a two-finger handle, giving you the choice to carry the tumbler by either the main side handle or the lid itself.
Another small but thoughtful detail is the straw. It’s long enough to reach all the way to the bottom, which isn’t something you can take for granted. Some tumblers come with straws that are way too short, making it awkward to finish your drink. Not here.
The handle also deserves a shout-out. It’s hands-down the most comfortable one I’ve tried. Many tumbler handles are oversized, which means you often end up grabbing them from an awkward angle that can tire out your hand. The handle on the Coldest tumbler is smaller and thicker, offering a snug, secure grip. Compared to some other tumblers, the comfort difference is massive.
I love finding hidden gems when it comes to drinkware, and Coldest absolutely fits that description. It’s a brand that flies under the radar for many people, but it shouldn’t. According to the creators, this tumbler is the result of 10 years of engineering – and it really shows. Yet it doesn’t feel overengineered or overcomplicated. I paid $55 for the 36 oz version, and I don’t regret a penny. As a bonus, they offer a lifetime warranty, which is rare in this category.
2nd place: Stanley Quencher ProTour
The Stanley craze has taken social media by storm. Their tumblers have become wildly popular thanks to a perfect mix of influencer buzz, viral videos, and, of course, eye-catching design. But the hype alone doesn’t explain why the Stanley ProTour deserves a spot in this ranking. Beyond the trendiness, this tumbler actually delivers on many practical features that matter.
Let’s start with one of the most important ones: leak protection. Unlike its predecessor, the Stanley Quencher H2.O, the ProTour can actually be considered leakproof. The straw folds down securely, helping prevent spills during transport. Naturally, you have to remember to fold it down (it’s not a magic auto-lock system) but as long as you do, it holds up very well. I’ve shaken it around in a bag a few times and didn’t see any leakage.
The straw itself is nicely designed. It has a long, narrow spout that makes sipping easy and comfortable. It’s especially convenient if you like sipping while driving. That’s how most people use these tumblers after all.
About the lid – it’s functional, but not my favorite. I’ve always had a bit of a love-hate relationship with Stanley lids. They do the job, but they aren’t the most user-friendly in every situation. My main complaint is that the lid can be hard to open if your hands are sweaty or damp. The edges are thin, and there’s not much surface to grip, so it can get a bit frustrating.
In terms of portability, Stanley nailed it. The ProTour fits perfectly in standard car cup holders. I tested it in three different vehicles, and it slid in every time without a hitch. It also has a thick side handle that offers a secure grip. Although it’s a bit larger than I’d prefer, it’s clearly well-designed. Personally, I still prefer the handle on the Coldest tumbler for comfort, but this one gets the job done.
One thing worth noting: the Stanley ProTour is clearly made with cold beverages in mind and that’s what the company states. While I occasionally use it for warm drinks, I wouldn’t trust it with piping hot liquids. The insulation works well for keeping things cold, but it doesn’t handle high heat as effectively. That might be a dealbreaker if you’re looking for a tumbler that works equally well in the winter months.
All things considered, the Stanley ProTour is a great buy if you’re after style, social approval, and solid performance. I paid $57 for the 40 oz version, which I find reasonable for what you get: a trendy, well-insulated, and leak-resistant tumbler that does exactly what it promises and looks good while doing it.
3rd Place: Owala Tumbler
I’ve always been a fan of Owala bottles and tumblers, largely because they offer great value for the price. My 40 oz Owala tumbler cost me $40, which is a pretty good deal compared to other premium options on the market.
The standout features of this tumbler is the lid. It’s slightly larger than most, which I actually appreciate. The extra surface area makes it easier to grip, twist, and open – even if your hands are wet or slippery. The real magic, though, lies in Owala’s signature dual-function lid that lets you either sip or swig. This is something the brand is known for, and it genuinely makes a difference in daily use.
For sipping, you get a color-matching straw that’s more rigid than the usual soft silicone types. It feels sturdy and high quality. When you want to swig, just push aside the cover piece and drink directly. That method is surprisingly comfortable too, though I’m personally not a fan of having to place my lips on the outer surface. Still, having both options is undeniably convenient — especially when you’re switching between relaxed sipping and quick hydration on the go.
The handle deserves some praise too. It’s generously sized and includes a thumb groove, so it feels very secure in your hand. It’s little ergonomic details like this that show Owala really thought through the design.
That said, you can’t call this tumbler leakproof. It’s better described as “splash-proof”, just like Owala says. It can handle light movement or small bumps without making a mess – for example, if it shifts in your car cup holder, you’re probably fine. But if it tips over or takes a fall, you should definitely expect some leakage. So it’s not the tumbler you’d want to toss in a bag and forget about.
Another thing to note: while the lid is dishwasher safe, the cup part isn’t. Owala recommends handwashing it to maintain its finish and insulation performance. It’s a minor inconvenience, but something worth keeping in mind.
At the end of the day, Owala delivers a solid product (as always). Functional, thoughtfully designed, and reasonably priced. And of course, it wouldn’t be Owala without a wide range of vibrant color options, seasonal drops, and limited-edition styles. The variety is honestly half the fun, and it’s part of the reason I keep coming back to this brand.
4th Place: Simple Modern Trek Tumbler
At first glance, the Simple Modern Trek Tumbler might seem a bit plain, but don’t let its modest appearance fool you. Priced at $35 for the 40 oz size, it’s the most affordable tumbler in my collection, and that price-to-value ratio is where it truly stands out.
What surprised me most was its impressive performance in insulation tests. Out of all the tumblers I tested, it kept water the coldest after 24 hours without ice. And when it comes to heat retention, it performed on par with the Coldest tumbler, which is known for its thermal performance. At one point, I left tea in it for a full 12 hours, forgot about it for another 12, and when I finally poured it out, the liquid still felt warm to the touch. That’s remarkable.
The handle deserves a mention too. It has a subtle wave on the inside that makes it more ergonomic than it appears. It’s thick enough to provide a solid grip and feels surprisingly comfortable during use.
That said, the lid is where this tumbler falls a bit short. It’s quite thin, and there isn’t much surface area to grab. This makes opening it a bit awkward, especially if your hands are wet or sweaty.
The Simple Modern Trek Tumbler is a great under-the-radar option. It’s affordable, performs impressively with both hot and cold drinks, and offers decent portability with its uniquely shaped handle. However, it does feel basic compared to premium tumblers loaded with extra features, like the Coldest. Still, if you’re on a budget and care more about function than flash, this tumbler is easily the smartest buy in its price range.
5th Place: Hydro Flask Travel Tumbler
Hydro Flask sits in a similar category to Owala when it comes to value for money. I paid $35 for the 32 oz size, which is quite reasonable compared to Stanley or Coldest options.
It’s a solid tumbler made with high-quality materials, and it just feels good in your hand. The insulation does exactly what you expect it to do, keeping drinks cold for hours, and the overall build quality is excellent, which is pretty standard for Hydro Flask products.
Now, if you’ve been following this blog for a while, you probably know I have a soft spot for Hydro Flask drinkware. So why doesn’t it make the top three?
Well, the lid was a bit of a disappointment. I expected something more refined. Instead of a screw-on lid, it uses a very thin flap mechanism. I mean really thin, almost flimsy. There’s this tiny tab you have to push upward to open it, but it’s so small that you can’t use your finger comfortably. You have to use your fingernail, and I’m not exaggerating when I say it’s actually hurt my nails a few times. It feels like an oversight in an otherwise well-designed product.
That said, there are a couple of clever features. The straw is connected to a removable rubber piece, which can be popped out if needed. That leaves a fairly large opening you can use to pour liquid without taking off the entire lid, and I actually do that more often than not.
One limitation to be aware of: this tumbler isn’t meant for hot drinks. And just like the Owala, it’s splash-proof rather than leakproof. So it can handle a few bumps, but don’t trust it in your backpack or if it tips over completely.
Still, despite the lid issues, the Hydro Flask tumbler holds its own among the competition. The price reflects the quality you’re getting, and interestingly, I paid $10 less for this 32 oz tumbler than for my Hydro Flask bottle of the same size. So if you’re on a budget and don’t need a leakproof option, their tumbler might actually be the smarter buy.
6th Place: YETI Rambler Tumbler
YETI has long been a symbol of rugged quality, and their tumbler is no exception. From the moment you pick it up, you can feel the difference: thick walls, sturdy build, and premium materials that scream DURABILITY. In fact, out of all the tumblers in my collection, YETI’s are hands down the toughest. If you’re someone who spends a lot of time outdoors, you can be sure it can handle rough camping trips, accidental falls, and daily wear with ease.
What surprised me is that the YETI tumbler isn’t as expensive as you might expect. Yes, the brand has a premium image and some of their other drinkware products can be quite pricey, but I paid $45 for the 42 oz size – cheaper than a comparable Stanley, which honestly earned YETI some extra points in my book. While some might say you’re partially paying for the logo, I think the build quality more than justifies the cost.
Now, onto my critiques. First, YETI doesn’t recommend using this tumbler with hot liquids. That limits its versatility right out of the gate. If you absolutely need to use it for hot drinks, they do offer a MagSlider lid as a separate purchase, which is better suited for heat. Still, it would’ve been nice if the default setup was more versatile.
The straw lid is another sticking point. While it’s made with the same high-quality materials, it suffers from the same issue I encountered with the Hydro Flask tumbler: opening it can be annoying. It doesn’t screw on and off. Instead, you have to push up a small tab, and I often struggle with it.
Lastly, the handle could use some design refinement. It’s large but quite thin, and I find the grip less comfortable than on other tumblers with thicker, more ergonomic handles.
In the end, YETI is YETI. If you’re a fan of the brand like I am, you’ll probably consider this tumbler a worthwhile purchase. It’s not my personal favorite, but it does its job exceptionally well, especially when it comes to long-lasting durability. If you’re hard on your gear, this one’s built to last.
How to Choose a Good Tumbler
Choosing a tumbler isn’t just about picking the prettiest one in your favorite color. Whether you’re commuting, hiking, working from home, or trying to drink more water throughout the day, your tumbler should suit your routine and last for years.
1. Insulation Quality
Insulation is what separates a $10 tumbler from a $40+ one. The gold standard for a premium tumbler is 24 hours of cold (with ice) and 12 hours of hot.
Most high-end tumblers use double-wall vacuum insulation, but some, like the Coldest tumbler, go a step further with triple-wall insulation for even better performance. This added layer can make a noticeable difference, especially in extreme temperatures.
Also, check the product details: not all tumblers are meant for hot liquids. Some lids can pop off or leak under pressure, and some models simply don’t insulate heat well. If you drink coffee or tea, confirm that the tumbler is explicitly rated for both hot and cold beverages.
2. Lid Type & Leak Resistance
Lids come in several styles, and the right one depends on how and where you’ll use your tumbler:
- Straw lids: Great for cold drinks and sipping on the go, but rarely leakproof.
- Flip lids: Handy for hot drinks and often more spill-resistant.
- Twist-seal or screw-on lids: Usually the best option if you need a truly leakproof seal.
Keep an eye out for terms like “splashproof” or “spillproof” – these do not mean leakproof. A splashproof lid might survive a bump on your desk but will still leak in your bag or backpack.
If you plan to toss your tumbler in a bag or backpack, look specifically for leakproof lids, and read reviews to verify real-world performance.
3. Size & Cup Holder Compatibility
Most tumblers come in popular sizes like 24 oz, 30 oz, or 40 oz. Larger tumblers mean fewer refills—but also more weight and bulk.
If you plan to use your tumbler in the car, cupholder compatibility is a must. The good news? All tumblers in this ranking should fit a standard car cupholder, but it’s always smart to double-check. Most cupholders are about 3 inches in diameter, but this can vary slightly depending on the vehicle.
Look for tumblers with a narrow base design if you want a larger size that still fits securely.
4. Material & Build Quality
Look for 18/8 stainless steel (also known as food-grade 304 steel). It’s durable, rust-resistant, and won’t retain flavors or odors. Cheaper alternatives may feel similar at first but tend to dent, scratch, or degrade more quickly over time.
Also worth checking:
- Is the exterior powder-coated or otherwise protected against chips and scratches?
- Is the inside electro-polished to resist staining and odor buildup?
5. Ease of Cleaning
Tumblers need to be cleaned regularly, especially if you’re switching between water, coffee, and smoothies. A wide-mouth opening makes cleaning much easier, and so does a simple lid design without too many hard-to-reach parts.
Dishwasher safety is not a given. Even some premium brands recommend hand-washing to preserve insulation and color. For example, Owala tumblers are usually not dishwasher safe, so always check the label or manufacturer’s website.
Lids often get the grimiest, especially under rubber seals. If your lid has multiple components, you may need a brush set to clean it properly.
6. Ergonomics & Portability
- Handle vs. no handle: A handle adds comfort and grip, especially for larger tumblers—but it can be a nuisance if you’re packing your tumbler in a tight space.
- Weight: Bigger or triple-insulated tumblers can get heavy when full. If portability matters, keep this in mind.
- Grip: Matte or powder-coated finishes are easier to hold, especially when your hands are wet, sweaty, or gloved.
7. Style & Aesthetics
Function comes first, but you’ll be more likely to use your tumbler daily if you like how it looks. Most popular brands offer multiple colors, seasonal drops, and even customizable lids or engravings. If you’re investing in a high-quality tumbler, you might as well love the design.
Final Thoughts
After testing tumblers from well-known and lesser-known brands, a few clear takeaways emerged. If you’re looking for the best all-rounder in terms of insulation, design, versatility, and leakproof performance, the Coldest tumbler quietly steals the show.
While not as famous as Stanley or YETI, it impressed with its thoughtful features like multiple lids, incredible leak resistance (even with a straw), standout aesthetics, and excellent insulation. It feels like a product made with intention rather than trend-chasing.
But if you’re after a specific strength, like ruggedness (YETI), brand prestige (Stanley), or budget-friendliness (Owala, Hydro Flask, Simple Modern), you won’t go wrong with any of the top-ranked options.
Jeremiah Kowalski
Hey there! I’m Jeremiah, the guy behind WaterBottleAdvisor.com. I used to have a bad habit of guzzling sodas while working remotely, but thanks to reusable water bottles, I’ve turned my hydration game around. After testing over 50 bottles, I’m here to help you find the perfect one to make staying hydrated a joy, not a chore. When I’m not reviewing bottles, you’ll likely find me scaling steep trails around the world, trusty water bottle in hand.
